Modular Construction: Pros and Cons (2024)

There’s a strong trend toward the modular construction approach—in fact, the global market is expected to reach $175 billion by 2025.

But why are more companies building modular structures? Is modular construction cheaper than other methods? What advantages do modular construction techniques bring to the table?

Modular construction is gaining more attention, and for good reason. Before we dive into the pros and cons, let’s define the modular construction system so we’re all on the same page.

Table of Contents

What is modular construction?

Modular construction techniques involve manufacturing the components of a structure in a factory that will later be assembled on-site. You may have heard this described as “off-site construction” or “prefabrication”—these terms are interchangeable with modular construction.

Modular construction follows the same process as other types of building with one significant difference—it takes the most time-consuming parts of a project off-site to improve construction speed. This offers more scalability and makes repetitive volume building possible.

The pros of modular construction

These three key advantages of modular construction show why this practice is gaining traction throughout the industry:

1. Modular construction is more affordable and efficient

When you build structures on-site, material and labour costs add up quickly. And in many areas, skilled labour is in short supply and comes at a premium price. Modular construction manufacturers attract competitive and skilled workers. Manufacturers also have the advantage of better access to raw materials and logistics like rail cars.

Modular construction is more efficient in the sense that factory and site work can happen simultaneously. This significantly speeds up construction time without sacrificing quality.

Modular Construction: Pros and Cons (1)

2. Modular construction creates less waste and requires little space

A case study by WRAP UK suggests that modular construction can reduce on-site material waste by up to 90% over traditional construction methods. With environmental concerns growing in the industry, modular construction is becoming a popular choice to limit the waste produced on each project.

Modular construction also helps keep the site clean and safe while providing crews more space to do their job. When building components off-site, there’s less clutter and concern about theft, particularly in compact urban settings.

Free eBook: Quick guide to Lean practices for construction professionals

3. Modular construction helps eliminate unpredictable delays

Weather is a huge factor in construction delays, but with modular construction, it isn’t a problem.

By fabricating building components in a controlled environment, projects are less prone to delays and come with an additional benefit—workers have safe, comfortable conditions in which they can be more productive, leading to higher-quality products.

On-site installations also go faster. Most components arrive outfitted with flooring, plumbing, and electrical fixtures, further reducing the odds of delays.

The cons of modular construction

Like any construction method, modular construction comes with some challenges, including:

1. The transportation of modular structures comes with costs and risks

Because modular construction components are prefabricated away from the job site, you have to consider transportation costs and the risk of damage during transport. It only takes one mishap during transportation to cause a significant setback.

Transportation and rigging companies have to put a lot of time and effort into planning the logistics of moving around modular construction components. To mitigate the risk of damaging those components, transportation costs can take up a large portion of any project’s budget.

Modular Construction: Pros and Cons (2)

2. There’s a lack of customization with modular construction

Modular construction involves the mass production of components, which is perfect for apartment buildings, hotels, and subdivision homes, but not for projects where custom designs and sizes are needed. Using modular construction to create unique components basically eliminates the time and cost advantages.

Customization is the single biggest advantage that on-site construction has over modular construction. Even slight changes in plan designs can have significant costs.

3. There are few options outside of modular home construction

The number of manufacturers fabricating components for commercial products is growing, but the majority of them focus on creating single-family homes. Many of the benefits of modular construction don’t extend to other more complex projects. Modular manufacturers that have the capabilities and financial capacities to deliver commercial products are quite limited.

Learn more: Why Construction Scheduling Software is More Efficient

However, due to the current and projected growth of the modular construction industry, this con might not stay on the list for too long.

Is modular construction the future of the industry?

While modular construction has only achieved a foothold in a few countries so far, it has the potential to deliver annual cost savings of approximately $20 billion in US and European markets.

The modular construction industry is advancing quickly through the use of digital technologies, lightweight materials, and improved manufacturing processes. Manufacturers are turning around the old reputation of modular home construction and focusing on sustainability and the high-end market.

No matter which construction methods you apply to your projects, LetsBuild can help you stay on schedule, facilitate team communication and manage your workflows to get full visibility and better control of your projects. Learn more about how LetsBuild is revolutionizing the construction industry and get your free demo today.

Modular Construction: Pros and Cons (2024)

FAQs

What are the pros and cons of modular construction? ›

Modular construction has several attractive benefits, including cost savings, shorter construction timelines, environmental sustainability, and improved safety and quality. However, due to its unique design challenges, the need for advanced planning and collaboration must be addressed to realize its full potential.

What are the main advantages and disadvantages of modular design? ›

The modular is fast and easy to integrate because they are pre-built and usually require no calibration. Also, it does not require any specific equipment, thus suitable for any business type. The development cost is lower. Coming to the disadvantages, they have a limited number of configurations.

What are the risks of modular construction? ›

One of the primary risks associated with modular construction is transportation. Modules are often damaged during transportation due to accidents, poor weather conditions or improper handling.

What is the downside of modular? ›

Disadvantages of Modular Architecture: Increased complexity: Breaking a system into smaller parts can make it more complex and difficult to understand for new developers. Higher cost: Modular architecture can be more expensive, as it requires more time and resources to design and implement.

What are the benefits of modular? ›

10 benefits of modular construction
  • Speed of build. Modular building projects can be completed 30-50% quicker than traditional construction methods. ...
  • Off-site construction. ...
  • Minimal impact on your business. ...
  • Eco-friendly materials. ...
  • Cost-effective. ...
  • Attractive design. ...
  • Bespoke options available. ...
  • Flexibility of use.

Which of the following is a disadvantage of modular construction? ›

Modular Construction Disadvantages

The cost of transporting modules from a factory to a construction site is higher, with inherent risks in transporting large loads of modules. Costly transportation is the main disadvantage of modular construction.

What scenarios are more suitable to use modular construction? ›

Ideal for projects with repetitive room layouts (e.g., schools, hospitals). Suitable for a wide range of construction projects. Healthcare facilities, educational buildings, offices, and residential structures. Structural elements, wall panels, and more.

What is the lifespan of a modular building? ›

With proper care, temporary modular buildings have a service life of at least 25 to 30 years, after which the components are typically repurposed or recycled.

What are four drawbacks of modular homes? ›

Of course, modular houses have their downsides. These include less customization capabilities than stick-built homes. The cost of the land and construction of the home may be higher than some people can afford, land restrictions, and perceive quality issues. Modular homes may also have more a complicated loan process.

What is not suitable for modular design? ›

When individual parts do not fit together perfectly, a modular design fails. For example, modularly designed computers often require advanced configuration skills. A modular design approach also does not work for every product or product functionality.

What is the disadvantage of modular homes? ›

Of course, modular houses have their downsides. These include less customization capabilities than stick-built homes. The cost of the land and construction of the home may be higher than some people can afford, land restrictions, and perceive quality issues. Modular homes may also have more a complicated loan process.

What is the life of a modular building? ›

With proper care, temporary modular buildings have a service life of at least 25 to 30 years, after which the components are typically repurposed or recycled.

Why is modular construction cheaper? ›

Reduced labor and material costs

This reduced reliance on highly specialized workers translates to substantial savings in labor expenses. Adding to the savings, because of the standardized factory setting, modular factories benefit from bulk discounts for materials.

Top Articles
Latest Posts
Article information

Author: Prof. An Powlowski

Last Updated:

Views: 5656

Rating: 4.3 / 5 (64 voted)

Reviews: 87% of readers found this page helpful

Author information

Name: Prof. An Powlowski

Birthday: 1992-09-29

Address: Apt. 994 8891 Orval Hill, Brittnyburgh, AZ 41023-0398

Phone: +26417467956738

Job: District Marketing Strategist

Hobby: Embroidery, Bodybuilding, Motor sports, Amateur radio, Wood carving, Whittling, Air sports

Introduction: My name is Prof. An Powlowski, I am a charming, helpful, attractive, good, graceful, thoughtful, vast person who loves writing and wants to share my knowledge and understanding with you.